Personal Name vs. Limited Company: The Landlord's Tax Decision
Personal name vs. limited company for UK landlords: Section 24, corporation tax, SDLT, and dividend tax examined to help you weigh the options.
The question of whether to hold buy-to-let property in a personal name or through a limited company has become one of the most discussed topics in UK landlord tax planning. It is also one of the most frequently misunderstood.
The answer depends on your specific financial circumstances — your income level, mortgage position, portfolio size, extraction requirements, and long-term intentions. There is no single right answer, and the analysis for any given landlord involves more variables than a straightforward comparison of tax rates.
This article examines the key factors on both sides: Section 24, corporation tax, SDLT on transfers, dividend extraction, and the distinction between new purchases and existing portfolios.
The Section 24 Mortgage Interest Restriction
Section 24 — sometimes called the “landlord tax” — is the single most important driver behind the growth in landlord limited company structures since its introduction in 2016.
Prior to April 2017, residential landlords could deduct mortgage interest in full as a business expense. If your rental income was £20,000 and your mortgage interest was £10,000, you were taxed on £10,000 of profit.
Section 24 replaced that deduction with a 20% basic rate tax credit. The phased introduction was complete by April 2020. Now, if you are an individual landlord:
- Mortgage interest is not deducted from rental income as an expense
- Instead, you receive a tax credit equal to 20% of the lower of your finance costs, your property income, or your adjusted total income
- The credit is applied after income tax has been calculated on your gross rental profit (before deducting interest)
For basic rate taxpayers, the net effect is roughly equivalent to the old deduction — you still effectively get 20% relief on interest costs. For higher and additional rate taxpayers, the position is materially worse.
A simplified illustration:
A higher rate taxpayer (40%) has £30,000 rental income and £20,000 mortgage interest.
Under the old rules:
- Taxable profit: £10,000
- Income tax at 40%: £4,000
Under Section 24:
- Taxable income: £30,000 (before interest deduction)
- Income tax at 40%: £12,000
- Less 20% credit on £20,000 interest: £4,000
- Net tax payable: £8,000
The same landlord now pays £8,000 rather than £4,000 — double the tax on the same underlying profit. For landlords with high leverage and high income, Section 24 can produce situations where a notionally profitable rental business creates a large income tax liability while generating modest (or negative) actual cash flow.
Section 24 does not apply to limited companies. A company can still deduct mortgage interest as a business expense in full.
Corporation Tax: The Company Advantage
Limited companies pay corporation tax on their profits, not income tax. The current rates are:
- Small profits rate: 19% on profits up to £50,000
- Main rate: 25% on profits over £250,000
- Marginal relief: A tapering rate between £50,000 and £250,000 profits
For a landlord paying income tax at 40% personally, the corporation tax rate represents a significant nominal advantage — particularly where profits can be retained inside the company rather than extracted immediately.
However, the comparison is not simply 40% (personal) versus 19–25% (company). The full picture requires considering how and when profits are extracted from the company.
The Dividend Extraction Problem
Profits inside a limited company are taxed once, at corporation tax rates. When those profits are distributed to shareholders as dividends, the shareholder pays income tax on the dividend — on top of the corporation tax already paid within the company.
Dividend tax rates for 2024/25:
- Basic rate: 8.75%
- Higher rate: 33.75%
- Additional rate: 39.35%
The combined effective rate on extracted profits is therefore:
- For a basic rate taxpayer extracting all profits: 19% corporation tax + 8.75% dividend tax on the remaining 81% = approximately 26% effective rate. This is slightly worse than paying 20% income tax personally.
- For a higher rate taxpayer extracting all profits: 25% corporation tax + 33.75% on the remaining 75% = approximately 50% effective rate. This is materially worse than paying 40% income tax personally.
The company structure only generates a net tax saving where profits are retained and reinvested, rather than extracted as dividends. The benefit is a deferral — profits accumulate in the company at a lower rate and are extracted later, potentially when the shareholder is a basic rate taxpayer (for example, in retirement).
The Existing Portfolio Problem: SDLT and CGT on Transfer
The structural analysis above might make the limited company look attractive for higher rate taxpayers with significant leverage. The critical question is: what does it cost to get into the company structure?
If you are buying new properties, incorporating from the outset is straightforward. You buy through the company and avoid the transfer costs entirely.
If you already own properties personally and want to move them into a company, you face two significant charges:
Stamp Duty Land Tax on transfer
Transferring property from personal ownership into a company is treated as a sale at full market value for SDLT purposes, regardless of the actual consideration paid. The 3% additional dwelling surcharge also applies to purchases by companies.
For a property worth £400,000:
- Standard SDLT on the first £250,000 at 0–5%
- SDLT at 10% on the £150,000 above £250,000
- Plus 3% surcharge on the full value
The SDLT charge alone can be £15,000 to £40,000 or more on a single property, depending on its value. For a portfolio of three to five properties, the total SDLT on transfer can run to six figures.
Capital Gains Tax on the disposal
The transfer is also a capital disposal for CGT purposes — even if no money changes hands. Any unrealised gain in the property at the point of transfer is treated as realised.
If you paid £200,000 for a property now worth £350,000, the £150,000 gain is a chargeable disposal. CGT at 24% would produce a liability of £36,000 (assuming higher rate taxpayer and after the annual exempt amount).
For landlords who have held properties for many years and seen substantial appreciation, the CGT on transfer can make incorporation financially unviable unless the ongoing tax savings are expected to be very large and realised over a long period.
Who Benefits from a Limited Company — and Who Doesn’t
Based on the analysis above, a limited company tends to make sense for:
Higher rate taxpayers with significant leverage who are buying new properties. If you are expanding a portfolio and will be buying new properties, purchasing through a company from the outset avoids the transfer costs. The benefit of full interest deductibility and the lower corporation tax rate on retained profits is material for highly leveraged portfolios.
Landlords who want to retain profits and reinvest. If you do not need to extract all profits as personal income each year, leaving them in the company at corporation tax rates and reinvesting in further purchases is tax-efficient.
Those with succession planning objectives. Shares in a company can sometimes be transferred more efficiently than property for inheritance purposes — though this requires specialist advice and the position is complex.
A limited company is less likely to make sense for:
Basic rate taxpayers. The combined corporation tax plus dividend tax rate on extracted profits is typically worse than paying 20% income tax personally. Section 24 has limited impact at the basic rate.
Landlords with low or no mortgage debt. If interest costs are minimal, Section 24 has little practical impact. The main advantage of the limited company disappears, while the compliance costs and extraction inefficiency remain.
Existing portfolios where transfer costs are prohibitive. If the SDLT and CGT on transfer cannot be recovered within a reasonable time horizon (typically five to ten years), incorporation of existing property is generally not worthwhile.
Landlords planning to sell in the medium term. Extracting sale proceeds from a company is tax-inefficient compared to a personal disposal, particularly where PRR or other reliefs might have been available.
The “New Purchases vs. Existing Portfolio” Distinction
The single most important practical distinction in this analysis is whether you are considering incorporating existing property or simply deciding how to structure new purchases going forward.
For new purchases, the question is purely about whether the ongoing tax position is better in a company. For highly leveraged higher rate taxpayers, it often is.
For existing portfolios, the question requires a full cost-benefit analysis that includes the transfer costs — SDLT and CGT — as upfront charges against the projected ongoing tax savings. For most landlords with substantially appreciated properties, the numbers do not justify transfer.
A hybrid approach — retaining existing properties personally and purchasing new ones through a company — is common. It involves managing two distinct tax positions but avoids triggering the transfer costs on what is already owned.
A Note on Complexity
This article sets out the key factors in the personal versus company decision. It is not a substitute for advice based on your specific numbers. The correct analysis requires a detailed model of your actual income, costs, portfolio value, growth expectations, and extraction requirements over a realistic time horizon.
It also requires an understanding of the legal implications of any transfer — which are outside the scope of tax advice alone. If you are considering transferring existing property into a company, a property solicitor should be involved.
For an analysis of your specific situation, visit our Property Ownership Structure service page or get in touch to arrange a free consultation.
The information in this article is for general guidance only and does not constitute professional tax advice. Tax rules change and the correct position depends on individual circumstances. Please contact us before acting on anything in this article.